Yamazaki 18 Years Review


“Great Single Malt from Japan ”

Country: Japan
Brand: Yamazaki 
Age: 18 Years
ABV: 43 %
Sample Provided By: Derek, USA. Many Thanks!  
Date: 13/07/2014

Colour: Chestnut/Oloroso Sherry

Nose: Rich and Intense. It certainly reminds me of a ripe Bourbon with tones of Pine Resin, Charred Oak, Vanilla, Cinnamon, Wood Polish, Orange and Cherries. But there's much more to discover in this Yamazaki. The Oak is very present but not in an overwhelming way. Quality Casks for sure and the Mizunara Oak adds a few nice aromas like Apples and Spices. Some Sherry notes as well but quite in balance with the other aromas. I also find Black Currants, Mandarin, Lemon, Honey, Herbs, Nuts, Dried Fruits, Malt, Butter Kekse (German Butter Biscuits), Clove, Salt and hints of Espresso Coffee, Orange-Flavoured Dark Chocolate, Leather and Old Cigar Boxes. The Alcohol is sufficiently integrated. Without any doubt this is one of the best Noses I have encountered so far. I'm happy just to smell this Single Malt!

Palate: Good delivery although I feel that an ABV of 46% would have been perfect for this Yamazaki. The Oak is much more present now. I also find Dried Fruits, Nuts, Brown Sugar, Vanilla, Molasses, Rum, Orange, Mandarin and Spices like Pepper, Nutmeg, Clove and Cardamom. Hints of Sherry, Bourbon, Earth and Floral Perfume. 

Finish: I would have liked to see a longer Finish. This Yamazaki deserves that. It's quite Dry towards the end. I find Oak, Cooked Dark Red Fruits, Pepper, Nutmeg, Clove, Aniseed, Caramel, Orange Flavoured Tea, Dusty Roads and hints of Cigar Ash and Espresso Coffee.

With added Water, The Nose gets extra Malt, Butter, Apricot, Menthol, Orange Marmalade, Floral tones and Honey. Palate and Finish do not benefit from the extra Water.

Rating: 88.5

Nose: 23 - Taste: 22 - Finish: 21.5 - Overall: 22

Derek's Bottle and the Sample!

General Remarks: The first malt whisky distillery in Japan was constructed by the Suntory Founder Shinjiro Torii in 1923 in the Yamazaki Valley close to the city of Kyoto. The place was chosen because its water, soil and climate were similar to Scotland. It was the first distillery of this kind outside Scotland and it used copper pot stills. Today the Suntory Yamazaki is the most popular Single Malt in Japan and it is exported to more than 25 countries. Since 1972 Suntory is importing its malted barley from Scotland and Australia. The spirit is aged in a mixture of casks from American -, Spanish – and Japanese Mizunara Oak. The 18 Years has won many prices since its introduction. It's not cheap and its price varies between 150 and 250 US Dollars, depending on the location.

Drinking Experience Neat: Very Good. I love the Nose. The Finish is on the Short Side.

Conclusion: The Yamazaki 18 Years makes it very clear that great Whiskies can be produced outside Scotland as well. This is without any doubt a quality Malt that matured on quality Wood. I really love the Nose of this Single Malt. It's rich and intense and you keep discovering new Aromas with each little sniff. I nosed this one for about 1 hour and it still kept me interested. It's almost a pity that you have to taste it as well. Because the Palate misses the great balance I found on the Nose. Here the Wood starts to dominate a bit. The Finish could -and perhaps should be Longer. I also feel that a slightly higher ABV of around 46% would have further enhanced this Single Malt. Despite these few - and minor observations, the Yamazaki 18 Years is a great Whisky that should be savoured on special occasions. I imagine it would combine extremely well with Orange Flavoured Dark Chocolate. 
推奨される
Jan van den Ende                                                                July 2014

Buchanan's Master Review


“A Student Rather Than a Master”

Country: Scotland 
Brand: Buchanan's Master
Produced by: James Buchanan & Company, Glasgow
Type: Blended Whisky
Age: NAS (Said to be around 15 Years)
ABV: 40 %

Colour: Amber

Nose: Sweet with Orange, Mandarin, Dried Fruits, Nuts, Oak, Cereals, Toast, Straw, Heather, Toffee and hints of Peat, Smoke, Leather, Apple Vinegar, Dark Chocolate and Sherry. The Alcohol is not fully integrated. 

Palate: Slightly Thin and Sugary Sweet delivery with Cereals, Nuts, Dried Fruit, Cake, Toffee, light Vanilla, light Honey, Oak, Straw, Orange, Lemon, Pepper, Cloves, light Licorice and hints of Smoke and Black Coffee.   

Finish: Mainly Sweet and on the short side with Sugared Cereals, Nuts, Straw, Oak, Toast, Orange Marmalade, light Vanilla, light Honey, Licorice, Pepper, Cloves and hints of Peat and Dark Chocolate. 

With added Water the Nose gets more Cereals, Oak, Nuts, Chocolate and Mandarin. But Palate and Finish don't accept added Water very well. Better sip it Neat or take it on the Rocks.

Rating: 81

Nose: 20.5 - Taste: 20 - Finish: 20 - Overall: 20.5


General Remarks: The Buchanan's Blend was established in 1884 by James Buchanan, one of the Scotch Whisky pioneers. Nowadays it's part of the Diageo Group. The Buchanan Brand Name is still very popular, a.o. in South America and Mexico. The Master is the personal creation of Keith Law, Buchanan's current Master Blender. At the heart of the Buchanan's Blend lies the Dalwhinny Single Malt from the Eastern Highlands. The NAS Master was launched in 2010 and is sold at an average 45 US Dollars. 

Drinking Experience Neat: Okay/Good

Drinking Experience On the Rocks: Good

Conclusion: As far as price and quality are concerned, this Buchanan's Master ranks between the boring De Luxe 12 and the much better 18 Years. I find it a bit better than the 12 Years but not by much. It does not come close to the comfortable Leather Chair profile of the 18 Years. Therefore, in my opinion, the 18 Years is the True Master of the Buchanan Expressions while the Master in fact is a mere Student.

Jan van den Ende                                                                 July 10, 2014